I'm really interested in going the more natural parenting route with next baby. I want to do a home birth or, failing that, a natural birth center birth. I want to use cloth diapers. I already do attachment parenting, and natural parenting is really just an extension of AP. So naturally, being the internet junkie that I am, I have started researching my options.
On the home birth/birth center option, I was able to find several references for midwives in the area, birth center options, etc. This is easy information to find and process, especially because I am already experienced with the birth process and I know what I want.
But, my god, how on earth is anyone supposed to make heads or tails of cloth diapering???
I have pored over different sites, considered cost options, and read, read, read. Most cloth diaper proponents figure that disposable diaper users do so just because they don't care are or ignorant about diapering in general.* This is not the case, at least in my case. I think the problem with cloth diapering is the staggering amount of options combined with the conflicting opinions of users. It is truly mind boggling.
With disposables, it's easy. You go to the store, and you have a limited number of options, all of which are fairly similar in style and use. They are put on the kid in a standard, simple way. It's really a no brainer.
But with cloth it is just not that simple on its face. It's not like you can go to Target, or Wal-mart, or Babies-R-US and pick up the supplies you need. You have to special order them from mail order catalogs or buy them off the internet. Then, you have to figure out what kind of diapers to buy: just pre-folds with some kind of fastener, pre-folds with covers, fitted diapers with covers, or all-in-one diapers which are fitted diapers with the covers sewn onto them. This is where is begins to get confusing.
Some people swear by the prefolds, usually with the covers. These same people usually hate the all-in-ones because they are expensive and purportedly wear out quickly. Others swear by the fitted diapers with the covers, but still use prefolds. Still others just use fitted diapers full time. Some people swear by all-in-ones because they are supposedly the most convenient option, much like disposables,except you have to wash them. OK, but how does that help me, the uninformed consumer, to choose diapers?
From looking at all of the various and sundry options, I am more inclined to go with either the Fuzzi Bunz system (a cover with an inserted prefold diaper) or the Kissaluvs fitted diapers with covers. Personally, I do not want to futz with all kids of different diapers. I'd like to have one, or maybe two choices.
But then I start looking at prices, and I realize that the fitted diapers (Kissaluvs) and Fuzzi Bunz are flipping expensive. Kissaluvs are about $10-$11 each, and for full time diapering, you need 24 to 30 diapers. Fuzzi Bunz are about $15 each, not including the insert, and you need 16-20 diapers and 24-36 inserts. So for one size, the Kissaluvs system will cost about $360 (30 diapers and 8 covers) and the Fuzzi Bunz will run you about $350 (20 diapers and 36 inserts). A typical infant will go through three size changes within the first year, running you a bill of about $1000, which is pretty much the same as what you'd pay for disposables. This cost does not include the one time costs, such as cloth wipes, an XL pail liner, washable tote bags, etc.
Then you have the different washing options. Baking soda, vinegar, BioKleen, BacOut, product after product, method after method. Hot or cold water? One washing cycle or two? Dry pail method or wet pail method? To dunk in the toilet or not to dunk? Use the rice paper liners or not?
Argh, this is all so freaking confusing. I am halfway inclined to drop the whole thing now and just stick with my trusty Pampers.
I am mainly interested in cloth diapering for the comfort value (cloth is softer and doesn't cause as many rashes). I also think that it would be a very economical option for an older child who's not going to change sizes all that much, or if you're planning to have a lot of kids, so the diapers would get a lot of use. I am having trouble determining how it is a more desirable economic option in the first year, with no children following the cloth diapered child. I don't believe that all cloth diapering parents out there just use prefolds with pins, which is the most economically sound option. It seems clear to me that, with the staggering number of choices available, people spend a lot of money on cloth diapers.
I'm now going to play a round of ask the internet: do any of you use cloth diapers, and, if so, would you please clarify a few things for me? How do you wash/care for your diapers? What kind of diapers do you use? How much did you spend and how many sizes have you gone through so far? I don't mind spending money for convenience, since I will be doing that anyway with disposables, but if I can save some money, that would be great.
Things that are dealbreakers for me: any toilet dunking, the whole wet pail thing, pins, expensive washing agents (I use All Free and Clear and Oxiclean for all my washing needs), any complicated process at all. I want this to be easy.
*At www.diaperpin.com, there is a hilarious little opus called The Diaper Drama, in which the author opines that parents are child abusers because they do not change their babies' disposable diapers often enough, and that disposable users are so dumb that they don't even read the notice on the disposable diaper package about how they need to clean the poop out of disposables before they throw them away. Well I guess I must be blind as well as dumb, because when I looked on the package of Pampers at my house this morning, I could find nary a word about cleaning poop out of anything. But, of course, I am an uneducated boob, so what do I know?
Recent Comments