OK, people, I put SPOILERS!!!! in the title, so if you choose to keep reading, be forewarned that there is information contained in this post that will totally ruin the book for you. I don't want any whiny emails.
I'm warning you!
Stop now if you don't want to be SPOILED!
Well, Dumbledore died. It was a shocker when I read the book the first time through. However, once I got over the shock and read it again, I was able to really see the reasons behind is rather than be fixated on the death itself. The death was a hard part to read, and I was ambivalent about the book the first time I read it. Now that I've finished the second read, I love it, but for many different reasons.
I think one of Rowling's crowning achievements in this series is her excellent characterization and the sheer amount of growth we see in the characters from one book to the next. I really felt that Harry had matured from the 5th to the 6th book, mainly because of Sirius' death. When Harry was having that conversation with Dumbledore in the broom shed about how he'd realized that Sirius wouldn't have wanted him to shut down, that was a big leap in development for him, mainly because his parents' deaths did shut him down to some degree, but I think the subsequent relationship with the Weasleys healed a lot of that pain. Not all of it, but enough to allow him to move forward in his emotional development even in the face of his godfather's death.
Ron and Hermione showed a great deal of maturity in this book as well. Age was such a feature of this one, the coming of age at seventeen for both Ron and Hermione, the apparition tests and licenses, the boyfriends and girlfriends. Herimone's misplaced outrage at the Half-Blood Prince and his potions abilities was particularly telling. Her jealousy at being outshined in absentia was really funny. I also liked the evolution and then rapid dissolution of Ginny and Harry's relationship. I've always liked Ginny, and I wondered when this pairing was going to come about. I am not surprised at the break-up, because it was necessary for the plot in the 7th book.
I loved the fact that Snape was a major character in this novel. No, I don't think he's evil. In fact, I think the act of killing Dumbledore was the hardest thing he's ever done. He screams at Harry for calling him down: "DON'T CALL ME A COWARD!" Because he truly is not a coward, but instead a monumental hero. This act has made him, essentially, a mole in the highest echelons of Voldemort's organization, perfectly placed to act in the final part of the series.
Dumbledore never feared death. He made this clear at the end of the 5th book when Voldemort has possessed Harry. I believe that he viewed his own death as necessary to clear the way for Harry to take down Voldemort. As long as Dumbledore stayed alive, Harry could take comfort and refuge in the fact that "the only wizard Voldemort ever feared" was on his side and was protecting him. Dumbledore also knew that as long as he was in the picture, Harry would never garner the strength to break away and do what he needed to do. I believe Dumbledore's death is a symbolic parallel to the 1st book: in the chess game Ron had to sacrifice himself in order for Harry to make the checkmate. In this book, Dumbledore had to sacrifice himself to clear the way for Harry to kill Voldemort. It was all part of the master plan. Consequently, in the death scene, when he was pleading with Snape, he was pleading for Snape to kill him, not save him.
Harry is now positioning himself to find the Horcruxes and destroy Voldemort. The reason he broke up with Ginny is symbolic, he was simply cutting his ties before going off to do his job. He tried to cut off Hermione and Ron as well, but they overrode him. In essence, I believe this is what Dumbledore was trying to teach him all year. The difference between Harry and Voldemort is that Voldemort has no friends and works alone. Harry, on the other hand, has forged relationships and has people who love him enough to help, instead of people who simply fear him. As Dumbledore said, it is Harry's capacity to love that will set him apart in the end.
I find it frightening how similar Harry and Tom Riddle are. Both orphaned, both betrayed in that process, both brought up in places where nobody really cared about them. And yet, they are a dichotomy in that same way, because one chose the path of good and one a path of evil. Neither can live while the other survives.
Of course, at the end of the book we have the mysteries: who is R.A.B? Where are the other Horcruxes, particularly the one that R.A.B. took?
My sister figured it out first: R.A.B. is Regulus Black, Sirius' younger brother, who was killed by Voldemort when he tried to leave the Death Eaters. We don't think that he actually managed to destroy the necklace, and that Mundungus Fletcher has absconded with it. As for the other Horcruxes, who knows? We'll have to find out in book 7.
So, the comments are open, please weigh in with your views, questions, whatever.
Recent Comments